First, make them price the same job
Bids differ mostly because they’re pricing different work. One moves the sink and another assumes it stays. One patches the floor where the wall stood and another leaves that to you. Each bid is a picture of the house that contractor thinks they’re working on, and the pictures don’t match.
So before you compare anything, write the job down in your own words, on one page: which rooms, which walls, which fixtures move, what finishes you have in mind. Give the same page to every contractor. Ask each one to price that page and to say in writing what they’d change and why.
Then read the bids room by room. Where one bid names a wall, a sink, or a stretch of floor and another is silent, that silence is a question to ask.
Scope
Look for verbs and quantities. “Kitchen remodel” isn’t a scope. “Remove the wall between kitchen and dining, set an engineered beam, move the sink six feet to the island, install 22 feet of base cabinets” is. Vague lines are where a price moves later, because nobody agreed what they meant.
Permits and engineering
Who pulls the permit, and is the fee in the price? Some bids leave permits out or write “by owner,” which hands you the paperwork, the inspection visits, and the risk if something fails. If a wall is coming out or a beam is going in, check whether the engineer’s drawing is included or billed separately.
Haul-off and protection
Demolition fills a dumpster fast. Is it in the price, and who hauls the debris? Who covers the floors you’re keeping and puts up dust walls around the rooms you’re still living in? Is the site swept at the end of each day? These lines are small, but they add up, and they say a lot about how a crew works in an occupied house.
Allowances
An allowance is a set amount held for something you haven’t picked yet: cabinets, tile, a vanity, light fixtures. A low allowance makes a bid look cheaper and moves the cost to later, when you choose what you actually want. Compare each allowance to what that item costs at the finish level you have in mind, not just to the other bids.
Then ask what happens if you go over. Do you pay only the difference, or the difference plus the contractor’s markup? Both are common. You should know which before you sign.
Exclusions
Read what’s left out as carefully as what’s in. Common exclusions include painting, appliance hookup, an electrical panel upgrade, repairs to anything found inside the walls, and finishing the floor where a wall used to be. An exclusion isn’t a warning sign by itself. A bid that lists none at all is harder to trust, because every job leaves something out.
Change orders
Something will change. You’ll pick a different faucet, or the crew will open a wall and find old wiring that has to go. The bid should say how changes work: written, priced, and signed before the work is done, with the markup or hourly rate used to price them. If the answer is “we’ll bill it as we go,” ask what that means in dollars.
Schedule
You want a start date, a length in weeks, and what the schedule depends on: permit approval, cabinet lead times, inspections. Ask who your day-to-day contact is and how often you’ll hear from them. A bid that names a finish date before anyone has measured the house is guessing.
Warranty
What’s covered, for how long, and is it in writing? A workmanship warranty covers the contractor’s own work. It’s separate from the manufacturer’s warranty on a dishwasher or a window. Ask who you call when something goes wrong, and how soon they come.
Bid checklist
Tick each line a bid covers in writing. Room for three bids at once.
| What to look for | Bid A | Bid B | Bid C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope | |||
| Names each room and wall, with quantities | |||
| Says which fixtures move, and where to | |||
| Permits | |||
| Includes permit and inspection fees | |||
| Includes engineering if a wall or beam is involved | |||
| Haul-off and protection | |||
| Includes the dumpster and debris removal | |||
| Covers floor protection and dust walls | |||
| Allowances | |||
| Lists each allowance with a dollar amount | |||
| Says how going over an allowance is priced | |||
| Exclusions | |||
| Lists what isn’t included | |||
| Change orders | |||
| Changes written and priced before the work | |||
| Schedule | |||
| Gives a start, a length in weeks, and what it depends on | |||
| Names one day-to-day contact | |||
| Warranty | |||
| Workmanship warranty in writing, with its length | |||
Your ticks stay in this browser. Nothing is sent anywhere.
Reading the gaps
Treat an empty box as a question. Send each contractor the lines their bid didn’t cover and ask them to price or explain them. The bids that come back complete are the ones you can compare on price.
How our bids are laid out
HomeHuge bids list scope, permits, haul-off, and allowances as separate lines, so you can hold them up against anyone else’s. The price is fixed in a signed contract before demolition, and every change is written and priced before the crew does it. The workmanship warranty is two years, in writing (proposed).
If someone else’s bid is lower for the same lines, that’s worth knowing. We’d rather you compare carefully than choose us on trust.
