Space found368 sq ft

Book a consultation

Guides

Should you move or remodel?

Most families who feel they’ve outgrown the house are asking two things at once: is there room here, and what would room cost somewhere else? The second question has firmer numbers, so start there.

General information, not real estate, tax, or financial advice. Your agent, lender, and closing statement have the real figures.

Half-packed moving boxes in a doorway, late sun on the wood floor, a lived-in living room beyond
Boxes in the hall. The cost of a move starts well before the truck.

The sticker price is only one number

When people weigh a move against a remodel, they tend to line up the price of the next house against the price of the work. That skips the money a move spends on the move itself. Selling pays an agent and the seller’s share of closing. Buying pays the buyer’s closing costs, a few percent of the new price. Then there’s the truck, and in some places a transfer tax.

None of that money buys a square foot. It’s the cost of changing addresses, and it’s gone the day you get the keys.

A remodel spends differently. Nearly all of it goes into the house you already own: the beam where a wall used to be, the cabinets, the floor patched where the old wall stood. Some of that may come back when you sell one day and some won’t, and nobody honest can promise which. What you’re paying for is space.

What selling costs

Agent commission is usually the largest line. For years it ran about 5 to 6 percent of the sale price, split between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent, and that’s still the common rule of thumb. It has always been negotiable. Freddie Mac’s guide for sellers gives a wider band of 3 to 8 percent, so if your agent quotes less, the low end of the tool’s range is the one to watch.

Seller closing costs come next: title and escrow fees, recording the deed, property taxes prorated to the closing day, and sometimes repairs the buyer asks for after inspection. A rule of thumb puts these at 1 to 3 percent of the sale price before any transfer tax.

Transfer tax depends entirely on where you live. Some states charge none. Others charge a share of the price at sale, and some cities and counties add their own. The tool leaves it at zero until you enter yours under “Change the assumptions”; a title company or your county’s recorder can tell you what it is.

What buying costs

The buyer pays closing costs too: the lender’s fees, an appraisal, title insurance, and taxes and insurance paid ahead. Freddie Mac tells buyers to budget 2 to 5 percent of the purchase price. Because the next house is usually the bigger one, that percentage lands on a bigger number.

Then the move. A local move for a family house often costs a few thousand dollars, so the tool starts at $4,000 as an example. Crossing state lines costs more. After that come the small things nobody puts in a spreadsheet: curtains that don’t fit the new windows, a rug that’s wrong for the room, a weekend of painting.

The gap in price from one house to the next isn’t a cost of moving. It’s a larger loan or less cash in the bank. The tool notes it under the result and keeps it out of the moving total.

What a remodel costs

At HomeHuge a remodel has two prices. The design phase is a flat fee: $1,800 for most projects and $3,500 for whole-home renovations and additions (proposed). It covers measured drawings, two layouts, finish selections, and a fixed build price, and it’s credited in full to the build if you go ahead. The build is a fixed price in a signed contract before demolition.

Our proposed price guides start at about $28,000 for a hall bath and about $65,000 for a kitchen. They are guides, not quotes. Your number comes after we measure.

A remodel also costs time and some disruption that no tool can price. A kitchen takes about ten weeks once the cabinets arrive, and for most of that you cook somewhere else. That’s worth counting in your own way.

Move or remodel, in your numbers

Three numbers. Type over the example with yours.

Example numbers

Including the design fee, which is credited to the build

Moving costs about $47,000 to $81,500 before you gain a room. The remodel is $65,000, design fee included.

Not counted above: the next house costs $150,000 more than yours sells for. That’s a larger loan or less cash, not a cost of moving.

This shows cost only. Which one fits depends on what your house can take and where you want to live.

Change the assumptions
Example: $4,000 for a local move
Varies by state and city; $0 until you enter yours
Where the moving range comes from
Agent commission5 to 6% of the sale price$25,000 to $30,000
Seller closing costs1 to 3% of the sale price$5,000 to $15,000
Buyer closing costs2 to 5% of the new price$13,000 to $32,500
Moving$4,000
Transfer tax$0
Moving, total$47,000 to $81,500
  • Agent commission, 5 to 6% of the sale price: an industry rule of thumb. Commissions are negotiable, and Freddie Mac’s guide to the costs of selling gives a wider 3 to 8%.
  • Seller closing costs, 1 to 3% of the sale price before transfer tax: an industry rule of thumb. Freddie Mac’s same guide puts seller fees and taxes together at 2 to 4%.
  • Buyer closing costs, 2 to 5% of the purchase price: from Freddie Mac’s guide to budgeting for upfront homebuying costs.
  • Design fee ($1,800, or $3,500 for whole-home and additions) and price guides: HomeHuge proposed figures, not quotes. The fee is credited in full to the build, so it is part of the remodel budget, not added to it.

General information, not real estate, tax, or financial advice. What you enter stays in this browser.

Reading the result

The tool gives the move as a range because the rates are ranges. Open “Change the assumptions” to put in a real moving quote and your county’s transfer tax, and to see each rate with its source. If your agent quotes a lower commission, read the low end.

If the move’s range sits close to your remodel budget, you’d spend about as much to change houses as to change this one. If it sits well below, the comparison leans the other way. Neither tells you what to do. A bigger house might be worth the cost of getting there, and a remodel that doesn’t fix what’s wrong isn’t worth any price.

What the numbers leave out

Whether your house can take what you need. A lot too small for an addition, a setback rule, a wall that carries the floor above: these decide the question before money does. That’s what an in-home consultation is for, and sometimes the honest answer is that the house can’t do it. We’ll say so.

The things that aren’t money: the school, the commute, the neighbor who watches the dog. And the market. Nobody knows what either house is worth in five years, us included.

Your house is bigger than it looks.

Yellow is found space. Example house, not yours yet.

Drawn for
Your house
Drawn by
HomeHuge, design-build
Sheet
A-05, Guides
Scale
Not to scale until we measure